New Year, New Audience: Retargeting Holiday Buyers Via Emerging Paid Channels

For many brands, the end of the holiday season feels like a finish line. Campaigns slow down, budgets tighten, and focus shifts from running media to planning what comes next. This mindset can create a costly gap.

Holiday acquisition only brings real value if brands stay active after the seasonal urgency fades and discounts end. Yet for many teams, far less focus and far less budget are given to this period as brands pull back, assuming demand has passed.

It hasn’t.

The weeks right after the holidays are one of the most important moments for shaping long term customer value. This is when new buyers decide if the purchase met their needs, and if the brand has earned a place in future choices.

Holiday buyers are high intent, but they are not yet loyal. Without clear and thoughtful follow up, they don’t slow down. They move on.

Brands that win in 2026 will not be the ones that gained the most buyers during the holidays. They will be the ones that treated the post-holiday window as an opportunity, instead of an afterthought.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Why Holiday Buyers Require a Different Retargeting Strategy

Holiday buyers are often treated like any other group. People who already bought and just need a reminder to buy again. That perspective overlooks the differences between what drives holiday buying and what changes when the season ends.

Holiday purchases are shaped by forces that don’t exist the rest of the year. Gifting plays a major role, as many buyers are shopping for someone else. This group needs follow up that is unique from people who bought for themselves.

Sales and short-term offers encourage people to act faster. Seasonal pressure favors speed over review. In many cases, the sale happens before the brand is even fully judged.

Post-holiday marketing is not about pushing someone to buy. It is about confirming that the choice made sense and that the brand is worth choosing again. Review happens after the sale, not before.

As the season changes, buyer behavior shifts and urgency fades. People slow down. They compare options, rethink spending, and become more careful about where they place trust. Messages built for December don’t always carry over effectively into January.

In this phase, trust, clarity, and usefulness matter more than speed. Buyers want proof that the product fits into their real life. They want to understand quality, dependability, and what makes the brand different. They are more open to other options and more willing to switch if the experience falls short.

That is why holiday buyers cannot be treated like standard remarketing groups. Retargeting built on repeats or discounts may catch attention for a moment, but it rarely builds lasting value. Retention requires moving from short term prompts to clear, thoughtful follow up.

 __________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Why Traditional Retargeting Underperforms in Q1

The goal in Q1 is to earn the second purchase.

Traditional retargeting doesn’t stop working after the holidays. Its limits simply become more obvious.

Lower funnel channels like paid social and paid search work best when urgency and volume are high. After the holidays, both drop. Search demand softens. Social feeds grow crowded. Results are harder to hold without increasing spend or leaning on discounts.

Creative fatigue adds to the problem. Holiday offers carry into the new year. Messages repeat. What felt timely a few weeks earlier now feels dated and overused. Instead of adding value, repetition signals that price is the only reason to care.

Audience strategy is another weak spot. Holiday retargeting pools are broad and built to capture demand quickly. In Q1, those same groups lack the detail and precision to deliver appropriate messaging. Gift buyers, deal seekers, first time buyers, and repeat buyers are often grouped together and shown the same messages. Relevance and results drop.

These issues grow under wider market pressure. Signal loss and privacy rules limit targeting detail. Platforms reset after holiday spikes, causing early year swings. And buyers are numb after weeks of heavy ads, shrinking patience even further.

Paid social and search still matter. They just can’t do all the heavy lifting alone. Reaching holiday buyers again requires plans that match post-holiday behavior and a media world spread across many platforms.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Emerging Paid Channels for Post-Holiday Retargeting

The challenge in Q1 is not a lack of tools or access to media. The problem often comes from brands showing up in the wrong places rather than shifting the focus to match how buyers behave after the holidays.

Emerging paid channels act as smart additions that fit a slower, more thoughtful, and more value-focused mindset. These spaces offer better context, clearer intent, and stronger first party data than many older platforms.

Used intentionally, they can help brands maintain visibility and momentum without leaning on urgency or repeat offers.

Retail Media Networks (RMNs)

Retail Media Networks are one of the strongest tools for post-holiday follow up because they work where intent is clear and identity is stable. These platforms are run by retailers and allow brands to reach logged-in shoppers directly inside shopping spaces, using real purchase and category data.

After the holidays, these networks help guide what comes next. They support refill needs, side by side review, and product discovery, which are common behaviors in Q1.

Because ads appear close to the point of choice, they work without requiring heavy discounts. Messages feel helpful to shoppers instead of disruptive, and first party data can be used without relying on outside tracking.

Post-holiday use should focus on value:

• Reaching recent buyers with refill or repeat use prompts

• Using gift data to suggest add-ons or upgrades

• Showing up next to rival products during review moments

• Highlighting quality and uniqueness instead of urgency

Connected TV (CTV)

Connected TV today goes beyond awareness, blending strong video storytelling with improved targeting and measurement, linking brand-building and results.

After a season full of sales-focused ads that create FOMO and urgency, CTV helps reset value by reminding buyers who the brand is and why it matters without fighting for attention in crowded feeds.

Connected TV performs well in Q1 as streaming time grows and holiday ad fatigue fades. High watch rates and rich storytelling help rebuild trust among buyers still forming long term opinions.

Post-holiday CTV should:

• Reinforce brand story for recent buyers

• Move from highlighting discounts to showing daily value and dependability

• Work alongside other channels

• Be judged by reach, lift, and real impact, not just clicks

Programmatic Audio & Streaming

Programmatic audio is often overlooked, even though it reaches people daily during moments when screens are not necessarily in use. In Q1, listening habits return to steady patterns as commutes and workdays settle back into a normal routine.

Audio works best as support. It builds familiarity and recall without adding visual noise. Strong listen through rates and voice driven emotion make it a solid match for video.

Post-holiday audio should:

• Reinforce brand presence among recent buyers

• Match messages to daily routines

• Reduce sales language in favor of calm and relevance

• Support message flow without overload

AI-Driven Search & Discovery

Paid search and discovery are changing fast due to AI tools, automation, and fewer clicks. New ad formats expand reach beyond classic keywords and shape how buyers review options.

After the holidays, search behavior shifts from rushed to review. Relying only on exact terms risks missing early signs of interest.

AI-driven search helps brands:

• Add holiday buyer groups into automated efforts

• Capture wider signs of intent

• Stay visible across many paths 

Post holiday use should focus on purpose, not volume. Ads and pages should teach and reinforce brand value. Results should be judged by support along the journey and real return, rather than last click results.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

How Post-Holiday Messaging Must Evolve

Messaging tone and style after the holidays must shift with the buyer mindset. Channel strategy alone is not enough. Holiday messaging pushes speed. Post-holiday messaging builds trust.

Repeating sales language may lift short term response, but it weakens brand meaning over time. Buyers no longer need reasons to act fast. They need reasons to stay.

Strong post-holiday messaging focuses on:

• Product learning and daily use

• Trust, quality, and honesty

• Ease, reliability, and comfort

• Loyalty signals that don’t rely on discounts

The post-holiday shift should move from closing the sale to building the bond.

Building a Cohesive Post-Holiday Retargeting Strategy

Emerging channels deliver the most value when they work together.

Audience detail matters. People buying gifts and people buying for themselves behave differently and should be treated differently. Clear grouping improves relevance and reduces wasted spend.

Channel order matters too. High-focus channels build familiarity. Shopping spaces support review. Audio maintains presence. Exposure must be controlled to avoid burnout.

Measurement must also change. Post holiday success cannot be judged by last click alone. Lift, added impact, support along the journey, and repeat behavior show true value.

When channels align through clear groups, smart order, and modern review, post-holiday retargeting becomes a growth plan, not a carryover from peak season.

__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

What This Means for 2026 and Beyond

Holiday acquisition is no longer the target. Retention is.

Q1 is a strategic turning point where brands either build on the value of holiday campaign investment or quietly lose it. At the same time, media and data signals are spread across more places than ever, forcing brands to rethink platform dependency.

The future of retargeting isn’t transactional. It’s intentional.

Brands that diversify channels, design media for real behavior, and prioritize long-term value will build stronger growth in 2026 and beyond.

USIM helps brands operationalize this shift through integrated strategy, first-party data activation, and careful testing, turning holiday spikes into lasting gain.

Putting Post-Holiday Strategy into Action

The weeks after the holidays are the right time to reassess, but don’t disappear. This is a chance to review what worked, while staying present with the audience you just earned. Ask important questions like: 

How did holiday buyers behave after the first purchase?
Which channels actually influenced re-engagement?
Where is performance overly dependent on a small set of platforms?

Answering these questions reveals where value is being built and where it’s leaking.

USIM partners with brands to turn those insights into action and design post-holiday strategies that protect acquisition investment and drive sustainable growth.

Holiday success shouldn’t end when the season does. With the right strategy, it becomes the starting point for what comes next.